Robach, 51, and Holmes, 47, attended iHeartRadio z100's Jingle Ball in New York City on Friday, December 13, and they brought along their respective daughters Annalise, 17, and Sabine, 11.
The "Amy and T.J." podcasters sweetly held hands on the Madison Square Garden red carpet, posing alongside Annalise and Sabine. They all dressed to impress with Robach and her daughter both rocking long, sleeveless dresses. Holmes, meanwhile, opted for a velvet blush blazer and black trousers and Sabine chose an all-black ensemble.
Robach and Holmes met as cohosts on GMA3: What You Need to Know in 2020. Two years later, their romantic relationship was revealed. At the time, Robach and Holmes were in the process of ending their marriages with Shue, 57, and Fiebig, 47, respectively. The broadcasters have since asserted that there was no infidelity.
It did, however, take a moment for the children to adjust to the changing reality. (Holmes also shares two older kids with ex-wife Amy Ferson.)
"My daughter, I mean, she's 10, I was still trying to get her adjusted to her new reality of her parents not being together. And I'd been working on that for the past three, four months," Holmes recalled during a December 2023 episode of the couple's podcast. "So I didn't want to spring on her that early, 'Oh yeah, by the way, you know that Amy Robach, who you've known since you were 1?' ... Well, I'm dating her now.'"
Robach, for her part, added that she had to continually apologize to Ava and Annalise for the public aspect of the GMA3 scandal.
"We thought we were protecting our children and our families, and we thought we had time," she said at the time "And we thought we had a right to privacy. And maybe that was foolish and silly."
Their blended brood has since come around. Holmes and Robach even took Sabine to last year's Jingle Ball in NYC. They also attended the Los Angeles version earlier this month.
"Yes, she is still and will forever be ... my #BabySabine. (Leather, long legs, and bedazzled boots be damned!)," Holmes quipped via Instagram on December 7, sharing red carpet photos.